Tuesday, February 6, 2007

You Missed the Funny Part, Leo

Anyone who spends more than ten seconds reflecting on life can usually recall dozens, if not hundreds of people who have had positive effects on their thoughts, opinions and outlook. Among the hundreds of people I've learned from over the years, two came to mind recently as I was watching A Thousand Clowns for the four hundred and eightieth time. Herb Gardner, the playwright, and Barbara Sproul, Chairman of the Religion Department at Hunter College.

I never met Herb Gardner. Like everyone else, I knew him through his work. But during my years at NBC I met people who had known him, as well as the director of A Thousand Clowns, Fred Coe. Through their recollections I felt as if I had known him personally. I was lucky enough to know and admire Barbara Sproul when I was a student at Hunter College.

Gardner created a richly-textured and moving collection of work that included the aforementioned Jason Robards classic, as well as I'm Not Rappaport, Thieves, Conversations with my Father and a cartoon series called The Nebbishes, which was The Simpsons of its era. His plays like his characters were unique and timeless. In a world of shallowness he saw complexity. In a show biz milieu dominated by tired and predictable old gags, his humor worked so beautifully because you could never see the punchlines until they were long gone.

Most importantly, Herb Gardner saw humanity everywhere.

There were no good guys, no bad guys, no easy targets.

In contrast with what passes for satire today, there was no anger in his humor. Every Gardner creation reveals insights from a wide variety of perspectives.

Just when you think that Albert is an irredeemable bad guy or that Arnie has sold his soul for success, they come back with soliloquies that reveal extraordinary depth of character.

And while I'm still trying to think of a redeeming quality in Leo the Chipper Munk, I even felt a twinge of sorrow for him. He was a professional comic with no sense of humor. And he knew it.

When Murray and Nick do their impression of Jefferson and Hamilton, Leo screams:

"You can't do an impression of Jefferson and Hamilton. Nobody knows what they sound like."

"That's what's funny" says Nick.

"You missed the funny part, Leo" adds Murray.

At Hunter College I was a bit of a curiosity. I was older. Already married and already with a fairly good job; the kind of job that most of my colleagues in the Theater Department craved. As a theater major with a minor in philosophy I loved every course. Unlike my early academic career, which I merely endured, this was great stuff and I enjoyed it thoroughly. My instructors were successful playwrights, directors, designers... authors and activists, philosophers and theologians... and Barbara Sproul.

She was an extraordinary teacher and a persuasive writer. She was also a serious, clear-minded thinker who was able to communicate complex ideas in ways that young minds full of mush could readily apprehend.

And she was a tireless activist, traveling the world on behalf of Amnesty International and as an outspoken opponent of capital punishment.

We had lively discussions. I was, of course, absolutely certain about everything and she was more patient with me than I deserved. In a very gentle and intelligent manner she steered my thinking, allowing me to arrive at conclusions on my own.

It's a rare gift.

What I learned from Herb Gardner and Barbara Sproul is that we should never let our current pattern of thinking get in the way of discovering what's new and beautiful in the world. And we should never let temporary setbacks color our disposition.

Unlike Leo, we should not miss the funny parts.

Herb Gardner died a few years ago. As I read through the accounts of his life in the New York Times obituary I could hear Murray Burns hollering at me: "Everybody on stage for the Hawaiian number!" and "I want to see a better class of garbage out there!" And then, at the very end, I read the closing line: "Mr. Gardner is survived by his wife, Barbara Sproul, Chairman of the Religion Department at Hunter College, and their two sons."

Merciful heavens. Can you imagine the dinnertime conversations in that home?


Anonymous said...

Herb Gardner's first wife, Rita, was in the original cast of The Fantasticks and she sang the title song in A Thousand Clowns. Music by Gerry Mulligan and lyrics by Judy Holliday.

R. Reynolds said...

All writers have good reason to worry about the camera turning its ugly eye on them. In One Thousand Clowns, an unemployed writer taking care of his abandoned nephew, writes a story about the benefits of unemployment, only to become investigated for his ability to provide child support. The chilling effect keeps many a story from being told.

Charlie Allnut said...

Murray didn't write the story. Nick did it as a school assignment, which alarmed this teachers, who called social services...

The moral of the story is:



R. Reynolds said...

You're right. It was the damn gifted kid who wrote the article extolling unemployment. Let's hope we don't get turned in by our own, Joseph.

Ric Nyborg said...

Really enjoyed this post today. After watching it again on TCM last night, I was surfing the net and came to your blog in IMDB.
Your last sentence is really great. I too have been always loved the film since seeing it originally in '66. I now see the greater depth of the meaning as I have matured. It was great comedy but I can still embrace it for it's great insight. Thanks for the "rest of the story" about the authors!

Anonymous said...

Through mutual friends, I had the pleasure of visiting the Gardners several times soon before Herb passed away. The evenings were magical. Herb was gracious, charming, and incredibly funny...despite the fact that he was in great pain and was continually short of breath. Barbara was warm, friendly, and oh so bright. What very, very special people. And oh, what a loss.

Barbara said...

Wow, I just came across this blog post because I happened to be Googling for Barbara Sproul, hoping to find an abstract or paper to show to people that a scholar, with respect for the scientific method and a minority view about the life of Christ and genesis (ahem) of the world's major religion, can also be a Christian. Which I am not, I don't believe in god, period; but Sproul's New Testament religion class had a profound and spiritual effect on me, as a highly reasoning individual.

I was also a theatre major at Hunter, so... weird. I never knew she was married to a playwright (screenwriter?).

I'm still trying to tell people that Christ was Jew, trying to reform Judaism; that immaculate conception was a mistranslation of the Hebrew for "first born son"; and that Revelations was not meant literally, was written as code to get past the Roman censors, etc., etc.

Barbara Sproul taught me that you can be a worldly, intellectual, rational, rigorous thinker and still be a Christian. I wish everyone could be enlightened this way.

Joseph Martini said...

Hi Barbara,

Thanks for the comments. When were you at Hunter? I can't access your profile so I hope you visit again so we can correspond.

Anonymous said...

Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now. Keep it up!
And according to this article, I totally agree with your opinion, but only this time! :)

Anonymous said...

good afternoon ppl. I'm honestly into shoes and I have been digging for that exact make. The prices as regards the velcros were all over 220 dollars everwhere. But for all I found this locate selling them as a remedy for half price. I exceptionally love those [url=http://www.shoesempire.com]prada sneakers[/url]. I will absolutely buy these. what can you tell me about these?

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye.

Anonymous said...

hello everyone. I'm honestly into shoes and I was digging for the sake of that particular model. The prices as regards the boots were all over 300 bucks everwhere. But completely I set this locate selling them for the benefit of half price. I really like those [url=http://www.shoesempire.com]gucci sneakers[/url]. I will definetly purchase those. what can you say about it?

Anonymous said...

hi there dudes. I'm honestly into shoes and I had been searching for that meticulous make. The prices due to the fact that the velcros are about 330 pounds on every site. But for all I base this area selling them as a remedy for half price. I exceptionally like these [url=http://www.shoesempire.com]gucci sneakers[/url]. I will absolutely purchase these. what can you say about it?

Anonymous said...

I happened to find this page as I was googling Barbara Sproul, who currently is one of my professors at Hunter College. I completely agree with what you have to say about her, she truly is an outstanding teacher, and in one month of class she made me think more than most professors have done over entire semesters. She has made me rethink the world, and see so much more, so much more color and so much more depth. I can't thank her enough for that. Extraordinary woman.